Nine months ago, I seriously considered going into the writing profession as a music critic. Although, I have decided not to aspire to be a music critic I still find this area of writing interesting, being the music nerd that I am. Assuming that I continue to focus on this topic, I hope to do an in depth study of different critics’ writing processes from choosing a concert to writing the final sentence of the final draft. To do so, I want to acquire the information through many different sources. Of course, the standard forms of resources, such as articles, blogs and books on how to critique music, will be used. However, every writer possesses a different writing style, ritual and process. As a result, I will also observe actual musical critiques to see how the techniques are used by reading magazines containing genres ranging from rock to classical. These magazines would be ones such as Rolling Stones and Gramophone among others. I will look at different news papers as well, such as the New York Times and the Washington Post. However, even with all of these sources, my research will still be incomplete. I also hope to interview some music critics in person or over the telephone for a more personal account. This will allow me to be able to ask questions that are tailored to my essay and more beneficial to my writing in particular.
After finishing my research, I will attempt to critique a concert for myself and apply some of the different approaches and techniques that gathered for the essay. At the end of my paper I will share my experience and look at the results of my own writing process. This will help cement the things I have learned into my own writing. Gathering information is good, however applying that information to one’s own work is even better, making it harder to forget.
By the end of this assignment I hope to see why musicians loathingly dread music critics with an immense passion. However, more importantly, I want to see what it is like to be a music critic and I intend to find out!
Thursday, November 12, 2009
Music and Writing
Posted by A Woman of Intelligence at 1:34 AM 6 comments
Thursday, November 5, 2009
Personal Statements v. Formal Essays
Last year, I applied to a few different Universities and found myself terrified of the application process. This was not because of the application itself but that a couple schools wanted personal statements to accompany the rest of the application materials (Yes, I know. It is hilarious that an aspiring writer was scared of the writing part of an application). With every application, I ran into the same problem. I had no idea what to write as the Universities did not provide any questions they for the paper. Of course, the fact that I had never written a personal statement and did not know how, did not count in my favor either. I never got over my anxiety of a personal statement. However, the article, "Writing the Personal Statement," by the Purdue Owl put to rest some of my fears. As I read through the article, I found myself comparing the components of a personal statement to those of a formal essay. This helped me to distinguish the elements of personal statement better in my mind.
There are some similarities between the personal statement and the essay. In both papers, there needs to be a point made which means a personal statement, like an essay, is revolved around a thesis statement. However, instead of a formal introduction, the first paragraph consists of a few sentences, if the thesis needs further explanation. The article also asks many different questions to consider when writing a personal statement. These questions are the same ones you would find on college applications for essay questions.
The ways in which personal statement differs from a formal essay is not in a way that is impossible to adapt to. In a personal statement, the writer does not take the pains of proving every point that they would in an essay. Judging from the student papers on Purdue Owl’s site (the link for which is located beneath the article), the paper has to be straight to the point, highlighting different classes and jobs that assisted the writer and their growth as a student in a particular field. However, the paper limits the writer’s creative expression, since it is direct and short, unlike an essay which welcomes imaginative creativity even with the five paragraph rule. Although Purdue Owl’s article encourages telling a story, the writer is still very limited between the amount of information needed and the required space.
Posted by A Woman of Intelligence at 2:00 AM 7 comments
Tuesday, November 3, 2009
Link to Vinikow's article with my comments.
Posted by A Woman of Intelligence at 11:22 PM 0 comments
Disagreements with Vinikow
For most of the world, weddings are beautiful joyous occasions in which families are united and everyone has a good time – except for the musicians. Contrary to what Van Vinikow wrote in his article, “Weddings? Just Say I Do,” playing for weddings is not all caviar and champaign. If a wedding takes place in Michigan, it’s neither. Although there is not much preparation needed before the wedding, the performance itself is stressful. Each member has to share the leadership role in order to pull off a successful wedding. However, this creates other problems within the group as well. Overall, Vinikow is out of touch with the normal reality of playing for weddings. I chose this article because in many of his suggestions and comments, the writer is so far from reality. It almost seems as though he is joking. I also found it interesting how different playing for high class weddings are from playing for middle class weddings
I have performed in weddings for nine years, both in ensembles and as a soloist. In all my experience I have never been served food at the reception unless the bride or the groom was family. In the past, a bride has given my ensemble money towards McDonalds while insisting that we play hours of music at her reception. However, the weddings that Vinikow describes in his article do not seem like ones from this planet. One of the last weddings my quartet played for was for a very adamant bridezilla. The ceremony was an hour long and the bride wanted us to play for three hours with NO breaks. Vinikow writes that when he performs for receptions that are three hours or longer, his quartet is fed a gourmet meal. When my quartet was talking over the ceremony with the bride before the wedding, I asked her to provide a meal for our ensemble. I thought this idea only sensible since the reception was going to last so long. The bride shot a look in my direction that said, “Why should I feed you?” People think that since they are paying you they do not have to feed you. In Nevada, where Vinikow performs in mansions and exclusive resorts, it makes sense that clients would throw caviar and cocktails at the wedding quartet. However, in Michigan clients are not as generous.
The author of the article seems unprofessional as a string player. Even beginning string players know that playing in the snow or rain with your instrument is a bad idea. In order to obtain an instrument of magnificent quality, professionals have to purchase one with at least a five character number on the price tag. A Violinist or Violist shell out the equivalent of at least one year at Harvard while a Cellist has to pay the equivalent of four years. As a result, I found it offensive that a professional string player performed “while huddled around under a pine tree as snowflakes drifted down.” Even a beginning musician knows that snow means the temperature is cold and probably dry and that if wood is exposed to such an environment it can crack. When an instrument cracks the sound changes and immediate repair is needed. An instrument worth one to four years at Harvard is not going to be a cheap fix, no matter how big your fee or “tip” is. As a result, it is a general rule that string players cannot and do not play in the snow or even rain. This is the one and only area where the bride will always lose in working out a discrepancy.
Many musicians who are part of a quartet, including Vinicow, believe that one person leads the group. However, this is simply not true. The first violinist cannot lead the quartet if all he plays are long notes. Hence, the role of leadership must be shared between all the members of the ensemble, although this can create tension within the group during the wedding. If there is a conflict of opinions then a specific member, usually the 1st violinist, takes charge. In the article, Vinicow states that there is always a specific leader. Anyone in a quartet, especially one that plays for weddings, should know that the leadership role is shared by all the members in order to pull off a successful performance.
Playing for weddings is not as wonderful as Vinicow makes it out to be. Being a wedding musician can be very stressful and although very little rehearsal is needed to prepare for it, the actual wedding is a headache. Between the bridezillas, the conflicts within the quartet, and dealing with the set up location, weddings are not all fun and games. Out of all the jobs I have obtained so far, I hate this one the most. The pressure to produce a great performance is at times overwhelming. After all, many brides only get married once and as a result, demand perfection.
Posted by A Woman of Intelligence at 9:46 AM 3 comments