Nine months ago, I seriously considered going into the writing profession as a music critic. Although, I have decided not to aspire to be a music critic I still find this area of writing interesting, being the music nerd that I am. Assuming that I continue to focus on this topic, I hope to do an in depth study of different critics’ writing processes from choosing a concert to writing the final sentence of the final draft. To do so, I want to acquire the information through many different sources. Of course, the standard forms of resources, such as articles, blogs and books on how to critique music, will be used. However, every writer possesses a different writing style, ritual and process. As a result, I will also observe actual musical critiques to see how the techniques are used by reading magazines containing genres ranging from rock to classical. These magazines would be ones such as Rolling Stones and Gramophone among others. I will look at different news papers as well, such as the New York Times and the Washington Post. However, even with all of these sources, my research will still be incomplete. I also hope to interview some music critics in person or over the telephone for a more personal account. This will allow me to be able to ask questions that are tailored to my essay and more beneficial to my writing in particular.
After finishing my research, I will attempt to critique a concert for myself and apply some of the different approaches and techniques that gathered for the essay. At the end of my paper I will share my experience and look at the results of my own writing process. This will help cement the things I have learned into my own writing. Gathering information is good, however applying that information to one’s own work is even better, making it harder to forget.
By the end of this assignment I hope to see why musicians loathingly dread music critics with an immense passion. However, more importantly, I want to see what it is like to be a music critic and I intend to find out!
Thursday, November 12, 2009
Music and Writing
Posted by A Woman of Intelligence at 1:34 AM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
That, to me, seems like a heavy workload. A whole bunch of steps and a lot of pieces. Granted it could make for one superb essay, but it just seems like a million years of research. Might help that it's in a field you love though...
I like it!
I think this is a good idea. I love how you took two very diffrent things and made it work for you in this project. I think you are sure on what you want to do and I can't suggest anything to you but to keep up with the good work. I think you are right on target with bringing the stuff we did in class together to the piece. I think you doing excellent and keep up with the good work.
~Terrence~
That sounds like it'll be difficult but worth it. Even watching a film that portrays a music critic like Almost Famous could help.
I, myself have considered being a music critic before I found out I wouldn't be that good at it. I've reviewed CDs here and there (cheap plug for the MTimes), it's fun, but you need to know what you're talking about. Good luck.
Conducting interviews (even one) can be a very time-consuming process, so while I like the idea of this project overall, I think some trimming might be in order. Research and analysis of recent music reviews, though, might be the only real focus we need (perhaps along with some historical pieces about the development/evolution of music journalism).
There are some scathing observations about music journalism, too:
"Writing about music is like dancing about architecture - it's a really stupid thing to want to do" --Elvis Costello
"Definition of rock journalism : People who can't write, doing interviews with people who can't think, in order to prepare articles for people who can't read"
--Frank Zappa
Perhaps your project could work as a response to such observations?
http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/booksblog/2009/jul/06/music
Thanks for the quotes, Professor Schirmer! They're great!
Post a Comment