CLICK HERE FOR BLOGGER TEMPLATES AND MYSPACE LAYOUTS »

Thursday, October 29, 2009

Adaptation: Worth the Headache?

Reading over Rachel Wills’, “Adapting a Novel into a Screenplay,” made me realize how much a writer has to let go when signing their work away to a production company. The author states that when writing an adaptation, there are three elements in the story that should be kept, “The main seven characters or so, the key action scene, the dialogue that drives the plot.” Everything else has to be axed. When I thought about this, I saw the huge gamble screenwriters take when composing an adaptation. By cutting so much out, the screenwriter can easily change the meaning of the story. Putting this into consideration, one must beg the question, is adaptation worth the gamble or should all novelists write the adaptations themselves?

In an article for the Writer’s Digest, screenwriter, John Folsom wrote about the ugly battle between Crusader Entertainment and Clive Cussler over the film adaptation, “Sahara.” According to Folsom, Cussler is sued Crusader Entertainment for “ripping the heart out of his story.” The production company came back with an even bigger law suit against the author, saying that Cussler “sabotaged” the movie by “encouraging his fans to boycott” the film. This is only one example of many lawsuits between authors and production companies over adaptations that have been unfaithful to the novels. So, I ask again, is it worth the gamble? I think so.

Even though the movie, Sahara, is not a faithful adaptation of the book, the film itself is amazing (I have to say, it is one of my favorites). This helps the author. After seeing the movie and experiencing the thrills from the various adventures within it, I want to read the book. I am sure that I am not the only person who feels the same way.

Considering the mess of dissatisfaction that some authors go through I have wondered if novelists should write their own adaptations, however Wills’ article makes me question this solution. How would a writer possibly be able to let go of some of their favorite elements in the story. As a writer, I often find it hard to erase a sentence or paragraph, because of the time and thought I put into the words. I cannot imagine erasing months or years worth of work in order to create an adaptation. I would give up after only a couple of minutes into the deletion process. In this case, if many novelists are anything like me, it is probably best not to write adaptations of their own books.

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Historical Comic Strips? Sweet!

Graphic novels serve as great entertainment. Now, according to “Not Just a Comic Book, Graphic Novels Teach Us History Too” by Tal Pinchevsky, graphic novels are intermixing with a different genre – history. This new way of utilizing comic strips serves as a way to make children more interested in history.

The idea to teach children using pictures, short sentences and conversational dialogue is brilliant. I am surprised that no one has thought of it in the past. Although some text books are overflowing with accurate and great historical facts, let’s be real. Kids would learn a lot more from something with pictures that took little time to read versus a book full of white pages and black paragraphs. When I was growing up, I would never pick up a book that didn’t have at least five pictures in each chapter. Even then, I would read only the words directly under the photos. Something about colorless pages intimidated me and gave me a feeling of dread before even reading the first word.

From kindergarten through my senior year of high school, I was educated at home. When I was in fifth grade, my mother presented me with my new history book for that year. After flipping through the white and black pages I found that there were no pictures, AT ALL (not to mention the writing style of the author was terrible)! As a result, I hid the book from my mother and conveniently picked out a different history text book for the year. She found her selection two or three years later. So, with all my heart, I believe that this new way of teaching children will be a great tool.

Not only would historical comic strips keep children’s attention, but they would also help some of the students retain the information. When I was given a text book, my response would be “What do I do with this?” I could not simply read a book and retain the information, a difficulty I struggle with even today (I know, then why am I an English major?). Visual aids, help people understand and remember the information, especially those with photographic memory.

I am not saying that all text books are bad and therefore should be removed from schools altogether, nor am I saying that they should be replaced by comic strips. Text books are important. However maybe comic strips should be used as a supplement to the dry material schools force children to read.

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Melodious Writing

My submission to the “Gallery of Writing” is an essay I wrote for my English 101 class at the Mott Community College two years ago. Before taking the course, I enjoyed writing but did not consider it a hobby. Composing anything, whether it was a journal or an essay, resided under a “homework” title. Majoring in English never crossed my mind. However, an essay that was written for my English class influenced me to rethink my plans for the future as I discovered a deep and beautiful love for writing while composing the paper.

When I enrolled in the English course, my career goals were significantly different from what they are today. I had the aspiration to become a professional violinist. However, I knew that if I had any chance of achieving this goal, I had to practice a minimum of five hours a day and enter a conservatory or school of a comparable level. As a result, all the spare time in my schedule was reserved strictly for practicing. Locking myself in a room did not bother me because I was infatuated with music. Writing, on the other hand, was enjoyable but there was no competition between the two subjects. I took the English class only because it was required, never considering to associate with the actual subject, let alone major in it.

One day, my English professor gave an assignment for which I had to write a paper about a favorite song and tell how that piece was important to me. This assignment drew a thrill out of me for composing. I was able to combine two subjects I enjoyed: music and writing. The song I chose was one that reminded me of a friend, Josh who passed away a few months prior to the class. My song of choice was “August Rhapsody” from the movie, “August Rush” and although my essay was entirely unrelated to the movie, emotions about my friend surfaced within me when I heard this piece.

The music was the inspiration for the essay. The melodic and harmonic themes and rhythms that are carried throughout the piece never weaken. However, they gradually build until they reach the climactic point of the piece after which the music becomes a little softer, almost meditative until the end. I decided on the title of the essay, “Josh’s Rhapsody,” after I wrote the paper. The “rhapsody” in the title not only refers to the song but also to his life. I wanted the pictures in my writing to weave together a melodic line in itself.

Before sitting down to write the paper, I did quite a bit of prewriting. Setting the stereo to repeat mode, I free-wrote for an hour to see what appeared on the page. Ideas poured into my head of different settings and imageries as the song played continuously. I had to force myself to use language that was more creative than what I normally used in my writing. I wanted the essay to be beautiful like the music so that the reader could see the images and hear the instruments in their head as they read the paper. As the essay progressed, I grew to love writing as much as the music pouring out of the speakers. As the finishing touches of the essay came together, I realized that writing was something that I could do as a career and not hate my job.

By the time I brought my paper to class for a writing workshop, my mother, had already cried over it. I was very touched by her response but considering that she was my parent coupled with the fact that she knew Josh as well, I almost expected this reaction from her. However, when I arrived at class that day, three of my classmates experienced the same emotion after they read my essay. I was shocked and could not believe that my writing would cause such reactions. Inwardly, I was overjoyed that I accomplished what had only occurred in my dreams – writing a piece which moved its audience from a calm relatively happy state, to an emotion that is (in my opinion) greater than laughter. This experience made me question if I should still pursue music. After several unpleasant experiences the final decision was no.

For the “Gallery of Writing,” I did not know what to submit, at first. Having only decided on my major a year ago, my writing portfolio is very thin. However, I thought submitting a work that played a role in choosing an academic major outside of music, would be a good selection. The essay is nearly two years old and is therefore not the best essay that I have written but it is among the favorites in my small collection of writings. Beyond these reasons lies one that is even more important to me. The two year anniversary of my friend’s death passed a couple weeks ago. As a result, I wanted to submit a paper that celebrates his life and reminds me where he is – in the arms of a loving Savior, forever.

Thursday, October 15, 2009

Story Over Ideas

I found Jeremiah Tolbert’s post, “Getting Started Writing Science Fiction” to be insightful, making me rethink the strategy of my writing process. In the post, he says, “Ideas for stories are a dime a dozen. Ideas can help put a story over the top, but they are not a good foundation for a story. The foundation for a story is, well, story.” Contrary to what the author points out in the article, no one has ever given me this advice. While a storyline is obviously where a writer needs to focus a lot, if not most of their energy, I never figured out this fact. My attention has always been on developing outlandish, yet interesting ideas while giving little thought to the actual story. Yes, I know. Blonde moment.

This article has made me reconsider my current strategies that I use when writing. Instead of spending hours brainstorming about the different twists and turns I want put in a story, I need to focus more on the story itself, spending more time working out the basics of the plot structure. As Tolbert points out, ideas create a great story, but if a story is not well thought out, then “it’s just an essay or a science fact article” and we all know how boring those are. I gag at the thought of producing such a paper. Of course, Tolbert does not throw inspiration out the window. Everything has its place. Ideas complement and add to the story and without them the reader would die of boredom, however they do not make the plot.

When looking for inspiration for your writing, Tolbert writes to look no further than the average, or not so popular, magazine in your doctor’s office. Even though he is a sci-fi writer, he does not merely pick up reading material in his genre of expertise for inspiration. He talks about picking up the “Woodworking Monthly” magazine to retrieve ideas for a possible character. I found this advice to be very insightful and plan on trying his idea out for future writings. What better way to learn about a character type than to read the same materials that they would read; materials that would influence and shape of their life? Brilliant! This encourages me to further branch out into even more genres of literature, including different writings from different time periods as well. Learning about other people’s way of life and traveling outside one’s comfort zone is extremely important to a writer’s craft.

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Lessons from Beatrix Potter

The movie, “Miss Potter,” is about Beatrix Potter who wrote stories such as, Peter Rabbit, the Flopsy Bunnies, and Jamima Puddle-Duck. The movie accurately portrays composition both in her painting and in her writing in ways that are relatable to me. Potter is not a stereotypical writer. She does not drink or smoke, but what she brings to the literary table is a form of uniqueness, unparallel to many writers in the different ways she finds inspiration.

In the movie, Potter gains inspiration from her pictures. She often paints a character before she thinks of a story to place it in. Her artistry and writing go hand-in-hand. When she is painting, the characters jump off the page and her imagination gives each of them their own personality before she even finishes the last brush stroke. In the movie, Potter never does any prewriting. Rather, before writing a story she is focused on developing the characters through her art. One could probably say that her painting is her prewriting. Although the plot is unknown, her characters are completely developed by the time she is finished with a picture. In fact, the movie placed a higher importance on her art than on her writing. This could be because her painting was so important to her inspiration and success. Her writing comes second to her painting and although her art cannot be compared to that of Monet or Da Vinci, it was definitely the greatest influence on her writing.

Although art gave her the greatest inspiration for characters and settings, one way that Potter gains inspiration of a plot structure for her stories is by talking to people. When asked about a new story she is writing, Potter begins with the main character and describes its personality. Then, after the full description of the character, she gains inspiration for the plot and tells the story. As a writer, I can relate to this aspect of her prewriting. Whenever I start a new work, someone will ask me what it is about. After honestly responding that I do not know, the characters come into my imagination and the plot becomes stronger in seconds. As a result, I am able to tell the person an entire story. Granted, much of the plot is torn apart and rethought of later but it provides me with an idea of what to write. I find this approach works for both plot and characterization. At times, talking to people works better than free writing.

In the way that Harold Crick was an autobiographical character of Karen Eiffel in “Stranger than Fiction,” Beatrix Potter’s paintings were autobiographical of herself as well. When her mother disapproved of her inviting a “tradesmen” to a social gathering, she would paint a character that was rebellious as well. Her paintings showed her emotions. Towards the end of the movie, her fiancĂ© dies. She tries to paint to comfort herself but all of her characters show the same emotions she was experiencing, hopelessness and fear. As a result of this, she decides to take a break from painting and writing. I found this to be very interesting. A composer’s creations are so connected with their emotions that when feelings are unbearable, the artist sometimes must take a break from their art while they recover.

In the movie, Beatrix Potter is happy to be alone and values her independence greatly. In a society where women are to marry, bear children and keep a house, Potter chooses to write and paint stories about the creatures in her imagination. Although she lives with her parents through her thirties, she is independent in her own ways. She is very opinionated and does not care what people think of her. This is very important for anyone in the composing profession. If a writer were concerned with other people’s opinions, nothing would ever be put on a page. Likewise, if Miss Potter were not independent or opinionated, she would not have written anything, let alone become a published author.

My favorite quote from the movie is from the main character, Beatrix Potter, herself. “There is something delicious about writing those first few words of a story. You can never quite tell where they’ll take you.” This is very true. The first words of the first sentence in a book drive the story forward and tell the reader where it is going. They are the words that grab the reader’s attention and are many times the ones that convince a buyer to purchase the book.

The movie, “Miss Potter,” portrays a historical figure that is a great example of a writer in her life and writing practices. Potter’s form of prewriting using art is brilliant and could transfer to any form of composition such as dance, music and drawing, among others. I found this observation assignment to be personally edifying in the sense of writing. Maybe when I cannot find inspiration in free writing or talking I should look into other avenues to find it. For instance, maybe I should play my violin or draw for inspiration when I have exhausted all other means.

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Similarities Between Writing for Children and Adults

While reading “Writing Tips for Writing for Children,” I was surprised to see how different writing is in some ways for children than it is for adults. However, Bethany Roberts makes some points that can, and should be applied to adult literature.

A “short and catchy” title is important in nearly all forms of writing. Imagine looking for a book at the store and all the titles were fifteen words long. When I see a title even ten words long, I say to myself, “I know what book I’m not reading” because to me, a long drawn out title means a long drawn out book. A work of literary accomplishment needs a banner that is going to command attention, which cannot be accomplished if the banner is too long. I am not saying that a title should be provocative or racy but it should draw the reader closer to the book and give them a curiosity about what lies inside.

The structure of a children’s book reminded me of an adult thriller. Both works move fast and provide a large amount of dialogue, while not sketching an in-depth profile of the character’s life and history. A person who reads a thriller is not interested in the character’s life story unless it aids in the struggle to catch the bad guy. The author needs to find ways to keep the story moving. Since explanation in a thriller is frowned on, writers utilize the dialogue to fill in any holes. Likewise in children’s literature, the child does not care about what the character had for dinner unless that is somehow going to help him or her in the story. Lots of dialogue is also used to keep the child interested. Honestly, what little kid wants to sit through a dry narration of how trains work? However, if two or more characters were talking about the mechanics of running a train, the child would be more engaged with the story. Thrillers use the same approach as well to keep an adult engaged in the story line. By using dialogue instead of narration when explaining certain things, fewer words are used, making the story move faster.

I really enjoyed reading this article, even though children’s literature is not my desired genre of writing style. I used to think that writing a children’s book would be easier than writing for and adult audience. However, I never considered the art of keeping a child engaged in the story.

Thursday, October 1, 2009

The Appalling Plagiarism of an Academic Authority Figure

From their very first English course, a student is given a sermon on the atrocity of plagiarism and the ramifications if one chose to do it. However, what is the point in these sermons when the professor does not even obey his own rules? In his blog, “Orange Crate Art: What Plagiarism Looks Like,” Michael Leddy exposes a president of a state university who nearly plagiarized his entire dissertation. I wonder how some English professors can steal from fellow writers and not be brought to justice when their students receive an “F” for doing the same. Receiving such a grade leaves a scar on the students’ transcript which is found in the grade point average. I’m not saying that this is wrong. However, because the teachers of these students speak out so adamantly against plagiarism they should receive a much more severe punishment than their pupils. Since the students have to suffer a degrading GPA, the professors should receive at least a black mark on their record and an immediate dismissal from their position --- no questions asked. By doing so, the schools would show their students that even in the real world they have to suffer consequences. As it is now, students look at the president mentioned in the blog and say, “If he can do it, why can’t I?” This matter is very disturbing. Don’t educators and authority figures have the responsibility to set an example for those under their instruction? How can they expect their students to write with integrity when they refuse to do the same?

In the blog, Leddy writes that the school which holds the plagiarist as president has refused to acknowledge this atrocity along with the school from which he received his doctorate. The act of plagiarism should not be ignored no matter if the writer is a student or an instructor. What message do these schools send their students when they do not stand by what they teach? Such schools should not be taken seriously. Such a disgusting act by the alum and president should be embarrassing enough to these schools, however their lack of initiative makes them look even worse. I would not apply to a school if it possessed a president who plagiarized and was not dismissed immediately. I would see their integrity as a school severely lacking.

If no one stands up to the authority figures in the academic world who find no shame in plagiarism, what will be the future for writing? Will plagiarism one day be the norm? How will honest writers protect their compositions?