Reading over Rachel Wills’, “Adapting a Novel into a Screenplay,” made me realize how much a writer has to let go when signing their work away to a production company. The author states that when writing an adaptation, there are three elements in the story that should be kept, “The main seven characters or so, the key action scene, the dialogue that drives the plot.” Everything else has to be axed. When I thought about this, I saw the huge gamble screenwriters take when composing an adaptation. By cutting so much out, the screenwriter can easily change the meaning of the story. Putting this into consideration, one must beg the question, is adaptation worth the gamble or should all novelists write the adaptations themselves?
In an article for the Writer’s Digest, screenwriter, John Folsom wrote about the ugly battle between Crusader Entertainment and Clive Cussler over the film adaptation, “Sahara.” According to Folsom, Cussler is sued Crusader Entertainment for “ripping the heart out of his story.” The production company came back with an even bigger law suit against the author, saying that Cussler “sabotaged” the movie by “encouraging his fans to boycott” the film. This is only one example of many lawsuits between authors and production companies over adaptations that have been unfaithful to the novels. So, I ask again, is it worth the gamble? I think so.
Even though the movie, Sahara, is not a faithful adaptation of the book, the film itself is amazing (I have to say, it is one of my favorites). This helps the author. After seeing the movie and experiencing the thrills from the various adventures within it, I want to read the book. I am sure that I am not the only person who feels the same way.
Considering the mess of dissatisfaction that some authors go through I have wondered if novelists should write their own adaptations, however Wills’ article makes me question this solution. How would a writer possibly be able to let go of some of their favorite elements in the story. As a writer, I often find it hard to erase a sentence or paragraph, because of the time and thought I put into the words. I cannot imagine erasing months or years worth of work in order to create an adaptation. I would give up after only a couple of minutes into the deletion process. In this case, if many novelists are anything like me, it is probably best not to write adaptations of their own books.
Thursday, October 29, 2009
Adaptation: Worth the Headache?
Posted by A Woman of Intelligence at 2:02 AM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I had always preferred when the writer of a book writes the screen play for the adaptation. I found it made more sense because the author knew the story front and back and knew what should be kept and what could go. It reminds me of something one of the characters in the movie "IT" said (not really sure if this quote is entirely correct but it has the same meaning), "if someone is going to mangle one of my books it might as well be me."
I like you guys arguement. I also feel it's best for the author to write screen plays of their work because they can't go off on someone else for false potrayal or not enough portrayal. One day in my futre I plan to become an Author and when I do I can almost promise you that I will be writing my own screen plays for this reason.
Post a Comment