Graphic novels serve as great entertainment. Now, according to “Not Just a Comic Book, Graphic Novels Teach Us History Too” by Tal Pinchevsky, graphic novels are intermixing with a different genre – history. This new way of utilizing comic strips serves as a way to make children more interested in history.
The idea to teach children using pictures, short sentences and conversational dialogue is brilliant. I am surprised that no one has thought of it in the past. Although some text books are overflowing with accurate and great historical facts, let’s be real. Kids would learn a lot more from something with pictures that took little time to read versus a book full of white pages and black paragraphs. When I was growing up, I would never pick up a book that didn’t have at least five pictures in each chapter. Even then, I would read only the words directly under the photos. Something about colorless pages intimidated me and gave me a feeling of dread before even reading the first word.
From kindergarten through my senior year of high school, I was educated at home. When I was in fifth grade, my mother presented me with my new history book for that year. After flipping through the white and black pages I found that there were no pictures, AT ALL (not to mention the writing style of the author was terrible)! As a result, I hid the book from my mother and conveniently picked out a different history text book for the year. She found her selection two or three years later. So, with all my heart, I believe that this new way of teaching children will be a great tool.
Not only would historical comic strips keep children’s attention, but they would also help some of the students retain the information. When I was given a text book, my response would be “What do I do with this?” I could not simply read a book and retain the information, a difficulty I struggle with even today (I know, then why am I an English major?). Visual aids, help people understand and remember the information, especially those with photographic memory.
I am not saying that all text books are bad and therefore should be removed from schools altogether, nor am I saying that they should be replaced by comic strips. Text books are important. However maybe comic strips should be used as a supplement to the dry material schools force children to read.
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
Historical Comic Strips? Sweet!
Posted by A Woman of Intelligence at 11:47 PM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
I was surprised when one of my english teachers made us read "persepolis" which is a graphic memoir of an Iranian woman. Had it just been a book I would not have gotten into it as much. Having pictures provided with the story makes it more memorable. I really think that more teachers should use graphic novels.
I agree with the use of graphic novels as a teaching tool. They can really make the events and people come alive. I recently just got Trotsky biography.
It WOULD be nice if they replaced our history books with comic books... it would make reading and studying a little more interesting, to say the least! I thought it was interesting to read that comic books are giving us history lessons in small doses, and at the same time made me wonder how much of history I've actually learned through graphic novels compared to history lessons in high school.
I think that the majority of people are visual learners and would benefit from having comic books to teach history and other topics that some might consider "dry." I honestly don't know a lot of history. I am not ignorant, but I feel that if teachers found more interesting ways to teach their students, they might have a bigger interest in the field of history. It could be a lot of fun, if we didn't have to read those boring books. Or maybe it is boring because I am not interested?
Using comic books as learning tools can be a good thing, but only if they're not overused. I remember preferring history books with pictures too, and not just script textbooks; but those were usually photographs of people or events in history. I think kids need the realism of a photo rather than the cartoonish quality of comic books to relate to their historical heritage. Also, isn't the comic book genre rather oversimplified as a rule? That's what makes them so popular, right? So, if that's all that you require a child to read, how are they ever going to grow in their reading skills? Just a thought!
Donielle, comic books would not be their only required reading. As I said in my post, I think they should be used as a supplement to the textbooks. Comic books would not necessarily be used for every subject. Just history.
Post a Comment